Wednesday, May 19, 2010 5:45 PM
In War With Cartels, What's The Answer On Guns?
Pressure from the Mexican government to stop cross-border gun purchases by drug cartels is giving some lawmakers hope for a compromise on gun control.
In a joint White House press conference with Mexican President Felipe Calderon today, President Obama spoke of shared responsibility on security measures to stop the cartels from buying guns in the U.S. Approximately 90 percent of the guns seized from cartels from fiscal 2006-2008 were purchased in the United States, according to a Government Accountability Office report released last year. The only place Mexicans can buy a gun legally is in an army-owned gun store in Mexico City.
Calderon has in the past year pressured Obama and other U.S. politicians to reinstate the assault weapons ban or ratchet up gun security. He has met with several lawmakers about gun trafficking, including Rep. Eliot Engel, D-N.Y., chairman of the House Foreign Affairs Subcommittee on the Western Hemisphere.
"I've met with Calderon about five times now," Engel said in an interview with NationalJournal.com last week. "... I hope we can get together and do something now to stop the cartels who buy guns in border states to go murder people."
Approximately 23,000 people have died from cartel-related violence throughout Mexico since Calderon took office in late 2006 and launched an offensive against the cartels, according to Mexican government figures. These figures do not include gang wars and other violence by cartel members operating in the United States.
Obama said today that he had directed the Department of Homeland Security and other agencies to "ramp up our efforts at interdicting" the money and guns that have kept the cartels heavily armed against more than three years of Calderon's counternarcotics campaigns.
Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano has also focused on interdiction efforts recently, telling an audience at the Brookings Institution this month that "there's probably not much appetite in Congress for reinstituting the assault weapons ban."
Yet interdiction alone can't stop gun trafficking, said retired Col. Robert Killebrew, a senior fellow at the Center for a New American Security doing a study on Mexican and South American cartels. Killebrew said increased enforcement of existing gun control laws will help in tandem with a shutdown of international gun trafficking routes.
"If the cartels can't buy guns from the U.S., they will buy them somewhere else," said Killebrew, a Second Amendment rights advocate.
"Since the assault weapons ban expired in 2004, the seizures of fully automatic and semi-automatic weapons in Mexico have gone through the roof," said Mexico's ambassador to the U.S., Arturo Sarukhan. "What we are asking of the administration -- and of Congress -- is to enforce what is already on the books."
At the start of Obama's term, Engel and 52 other House members sent a letter to the president pressuring him to reinstate the assault weapons ban because it could be reinstated without writing a new law. While he's disappointed the administration has not indicated support for the ban, Engel observed last week that "there isn't much stomach in the Congress to do that."
"This is not about Second Amendment rights, this is about selling guns to people who go south of the border to murder and to wage war against the Mexican government," Engel said. "What I'm looking for is something that can be done right now that I think would have a great effect, like closing gun-show loopholes."
In addition to that loophole, which lets someone buy weapons from private sellers without a background check, cartels can buy guns via "straw purchases," made through citizens with clean records.
Closing the gun-show loophole to shut down trafficking is one avenue being explored by lawmakers, including New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg's Mayors Against Illegal Guns coalition. Another soft spot is the "terror gap" being targeted by Rep. Peter King, R-N.Y., who introduced a bill last year to restrict gun purchases by people who are suspected of terrorist links. According to the FBI, more than 1,100 legal purchases of weapons or explosives since 2004 were made by people on terror watch lists.
"We must do all we can to keep our cities and communities safe from terror and violence," King said May 5 when he spoke with Bloomberg and others before the Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs.
Gil Kerlikowske, director of the Office of National Drug Control Policy, also raised the cartels as a global security concern in an interview with NationalJournal.com on May 4. "There's a significant shift from the Caribbean onto West Africa and Europe, and that's why the joint interdiction forces are so important," he said.
Killebrew says his study, due out in September, labels Mexico's cartels as "an international insurgency because they seek to threaten the power of government" and calls for a broader strategy to stop their access to guns.
"These guys are after quantities, so there could be more laws against buying in bulk, the way they have in Virginia," Killebrew said. "If you pitch this as a Second Amendment right, all progress will probably stop. But if you pitch it as a larger war against cartels, there is some compromise that could be made."

Griz
Saturday, May 22, 2010
So we are to loose our 2 amendments rights because illegal aliens come to America, steal weapons from Americans. Then take them back to Mexico to commit crimes. Stop the crossings and condoning them living here illegally sucking the system dry. Protect our borders and country. Stop the media from twisting the TRUTH.
JohnH
Thursday, May 20, 2010
Why do we not place the blame for the violence in Mexico where it lays, with the drug cartels that commit it. Instead blame is placed on everything else but the problem, then wonder we why nothing is done to solve it. Duh.
brian
Thursday, May 20, 2010
How about a little law enforcement, i.e. border security, to prevent the cartels from entering in the first place? On 9/11/2001, Islamic nuts bomb our buildings. What do we do? Wide open borders! the only country in the wrold with such.
Of course now days:
Border security = Racism
So that idea won't fly.
Bill
Thursday, May 20, 2010
Another liar publishing more lies to advance his un - American agenda, what else is new? As the others have pointed out, the 90% figure has been proven wrong so may times I am amzed this fool is repeating it yet again.
Nathan
Thursday, May 20, 2010
The GAO (US Government Accountability Office) is supposed to be non-partisan but even the Department of Homeland Security believes that the GAO report was misleading. From DHS:
"Department of Homeland Security officials question the statistic involving the origination of weapons as currently presented by GOA. DHS officials believe that the 87 percent statistic is misleading as the reference should include the number of weapons that could not be traced (i.e., out of approximately 30,000 weapons seized in Mexico, approximately 4,000 could be traced and 87 percent of those - 3,480 - originated in the United States.)"
So between 2004 and 2008 3,480 guns came from the US and over 26,000 came from elsewhere but banning guns in the US would solve the violence problem in Mexico? Clearly there is an agenda here that has nothing to do with violence in Mexico.
Mike Ebel
Thursday, May 20, 2010
The 90% is a lie and has been proven. They are not coming to America to buy semi-auto firearms for the same price they could pay on the black market for full auto machine guns. They are not coming to gun shows and buying guns a FFL dealer is still required to run a back ground check even at gun shows plus report more than 2 gun sales per person, a private citizen is required to think they are selling to a citizen and non-felon. So again it comes back to why would they buy semi-auto multi caliber firearms from random private citizens at gun shows when they can go to the black market in Mexico and get a whole shipment of full auto firearms of the same caliber for the same amount of money. And I would like to find where in America you can buy a full auto firearm for less than $7,000 unless you are police or military. This entire column is bull
Bud Johnston
Wednesday, May 19, 2010
Okay, I read the government report, and it does NOT say that "90 percent of the guns seized from cartels from fiscal 2006-2008 were purchased in the United States". It says 90 percent of the guns siezed and traced; BIG DIFFERENCE. Mexico has US traces done for guns that were made in the US.
Understand that what the report is really saying is that 90 percent of the US-manufactured guns that were seized were purchased in the United States. Do I hear a "Duh!" anyone?